If you’re a peanut butter lover, you have to try these new ways to use this storecupboard staple. Peanut butter is a versatile ingredient that can be used in both sweet and savoury dishes. While it’s often associated with classic combinations like peanut butter and jam, there are plenty of bold and unexpected ways to enjoy this nutty spread.

Ad

From upgrading the classic PB&J combo into exciting new forms, to loaded ice cream sandwiches, comforting puddings and more, here are some of the most outrageous peanut butter recipes that take the classic spread to whole new heights. Don't worry, we haven't forgotten about savoury recipes either – use up any leftover jars of the nutty spread in soups, ramen and even mashed into potato for extra creamy, nutty flavour.

Peanut butter isn't just a rich and creamy addition to recipes, it also has a wealth of health benefits. Read about the health benefits of peanut butter, the healthiest nuts and the top foods to improve your memory (spoiler: peanut butter is one of them!).

Discover even more peanut butter recipes and then read more about the different types of nut. Can't get enough nutty recipes? Discover our recipe for homemade almond butter and then read about the top health benefits of almonds.

10 outrageously good peanut butter recipes

1. Peanut butter-stuffed French toast

Peanut butter French toast drizzled with caramel icing served on a blue striped plate

Our take on the Hong Kong viral deep-fried toast, this version is stuffed with creamy peanut butter before being pan-fried to golden perfection. Serve with a drizzle of sweet condensed milk for an extra decadent breakfast.

Can't get enough? Try more French toast recipes.

2. Peanut butter & jelly doughnut ice cream sandwiches

One peanut butter & jelly doughnut ice cream sandwich

PB&J + doughnut + ice cream sandwich = match made in heaven? This seriously decadent dessert rolls many of our favourite sweet treats into a towering dessert for a special occasion. Plus, with shop-bought doughnuts, it only takes 10 minutes to make.

Discover more ways with ice cream sandwiches.

3. Mutton peanut butter soup

Miyan gyada (mutton peanut butter soup) in a casserole dish

Miyan gyada is a Nigerian soup made by slow cooking mutton in a rich sauce in the oven with a peppery peanut butter mix. It's a great recipe if you're feeling ambitious in the kitchen as the finished result will be truly worth the effort.

Find out more about mutton.

4. Spicy peanut butter & corn ramen

A serving of spicy peanut butter & corn ramen

It doesn't get much more comforting than a bowl of creamy, spicy, umami-rich ramen. Our easy recipe comes together in under half an hour and turns peanut butter into a smooth, nutty sauce to drench noodles, pak choi and crispy corn.

Try more warming ramen recipes.

5. Hot Elvis toastie

Peanut butter and banana toastie on a scalloped plate with ice cream

This sweet toastie is stuffed with crunchy peanut butter, sliced banana and topped with a sprinkling of cinnamon sugar. Serve warm for brunch or dessert with a scoop of creamy ice cream for a sweet homage to the king of rock 'n' roll.

Try our Elvis sandwich for a sweet and salty twist with bacon, then discover our most indulgent brunch recipes ever.

6. Chocolate & peanut butter pavlova

Three tiers of meringue topped with chocolate sauce and peanuts.

This dessert combines crisp meringue with a rich peanut butter cream and a smooth chocolate crémeux. The mix of textures and flavours makes it an extravagant treat for special occasions.

Try more pavlova ideas and find out how to make a perfect pavlova.

7. Peanut butter & jam pudding

Peanut butter & jam pudding in a large baking dish

A nostalgic twist on the classic jam pudding, this dish layers peanut butter into a soft sponge with a jammy fruit filling. The combination of salty and sweet makes it an irresistible comfort dessert.

Discover more ways to use up leftover jam.

8. Peanut butter & jelly blondies

Peanut butter & jelly blondie squares

Transform the classic PB&J combo into these jam-swirled, fudgy blondies. Crunchy peanut butter adds bite and texture and you can use whichever jam you prefer – strawberry, blackberry and plum are all great contenders.

Try more tempting blondie recipes.

9. Spicy veggie pies with peanut butter mash

egg wraps with black bean and rocket, vegan roast spiced squash salad with tahini dressing, spicy veggie pies with peanut butter mash

We bet you've never thought about putting peanut butter in mashed potatoes before. This veg-packed pie is topped with a creamy mash made from potatoes, peanut butter, lime juice and coriander for a fresh and nutty twist. It makes a great, healthy post-workout meal.

Get inspired with more mashed potato recipes.

10. Sweet potato, peanut butter & chilli quesadillas

Pieces of sweet potato and peanut butter quesadillas

Peanut butter is the secret ingredient in these plant-packed quesadillas. Fill with paprika-roasted sweet potatoes, creamy and zesty avocado, peanut butter – of course – sriracha chilli sauce and fresh coriander.

Find out how to cook sweet potatoes and more sweet potato recipes.

Ad

Enjoyed these recipes? Discover more condiment content

Gochujang recipes
Mustard recipes
Jam recipes
Lemon curd recipes
Marmalade recipes
How to make flavoured butters
Ways with flavoured butters
Best butter dishes
Herby flavoured butters

Which recipe has caught your eye? Let us know your favourite in the comments...

Sponsored content

Comments, questions and tips

Choose the type of message you'd like to post

Choose the type of message you'd like to post

Be the first to comment

We’d love to hear how you got on with this recipe. Did you like it? Do you have suggestions for possible swaps and additions? Or simply ask us your questions...

Ad
Ad
Ad
Loading...

Sponsored content